G3 was the lowest time for Melee.
G2 Had a broken parry.
G4 Had the old speed system and the new AP system
G5 Had the new AP system, but the new Speed system
G1 Had the old AP, old speed, and old leveling system.
It's kinda hard to choose which game, G1, G2, or G4 had the best time for melee. My guess would be G4 due to there being a servile thus being to get speed and other magicks easier than the Guardian.
But hey,
Originally Posted By: Power Card v. Infinite Start
Getting to 30 Anatomy and 30 Quick Action by level 10, was FUN!
Endurance & Health in G1 was a pain in the ass.