Finally figured out that they were arranged from down to up and not straight across.
End result:
12 34
56 78
1 - Adventurers Club
2 - Deadly Goblins
3 - The Expedition
4 - The Forsaken
5 - A Little Girl
6 - Quintessence
7 - Spears
8 - tehGRICH!!!
Though alphabetically, tehGRICH!!! is lowercase and it still should have been dead last.