Favorite Scenarios?

[BainIhrno]

To those still around:

 

What are your all time favorite scenarios? This thread is for both BoE and BoA, though as most of the great scenarios are BoE, I decided to post this here,

 

My favorites (in no particular order):

 

Shadow of the Stranger

An Apology

Of Good and Evil

Tatterdemalion

Truffle Days

Nebulous Times Hence

Adventurer's Club 2: Asylum

Tomorrow

Areni

Frostbite

[Quiconque]

Nephil's Gambit,

Nephil's Gambit,

and Nephil's Gambit.

[Lazarus.]

Gah! I had been keeping a list of scenarios and ranking them as I went, but I left the list on my computer back at home. Here is my list in order of how much I recall enjoying them (BoE only, it's too hard to combine the two lists into 1.)

 

Falling Stars

Emulations

Roots

An Apology

Revenge

Tomorrow

Shadow of the Stranger

Nebulous Times Hence

Redemption

Brotherhood of the Hand

Bandits II

Of Good and Evil

The Forsaken

 

There are a lot of scenarios (Especially in the 7-8 range) that I haven't played, and a lot that I've started and lost interest in (Which probably means they wouldn't have been makign this list anyhow) but anyway these are my favorites. The first 4 are in a league of their own IMO, and the next 6 are also great but a definite step down from the first 4. The last three round out the list.

[Prince of Kitties]

In no particular order...

 

Falling Stars - engaging plot, lots of characters, lots of hidden stuff. Some people have complained about combat balance, but I find that the "unbalanced" fights make it feel more realistic - some days you're up against a bunch of disorganized orcs, others you're facing Seraphim and Rokka that are tailor-made to kill unwilling targets.

 

Tomorrow - Essence spells, cool. Wickerman, cool. Fight with Cornell, really cool. Ending cutscene... amazing.

 

At the Gallows - This scenario didn't strike me as really great until the stuff with the mysterious purple-robed guy and the alternate reality business came into play. It never really got elaborated on, but the utter weirdness of it all was wonderful.

 

Revenge - this scenario gets a special place in my list, because it proved that you can make a scenario very difficult without making all the tough monsters magic-immune. This makes combat a lot more interesting.

[Tonweya]

Like one's children, they're all 'favorites'.

me

[keeper off]

Ooh, i just love BoE, but no particular scenario. ( I can't remember all I've played either.)