Is a making Geneforge in Starcraft even possible?
making geneforge in War3 is quite possible and I have even considered making one myself. Just haven't touched the editor in a while so I'll need to relearn a bunch of stuff. The orc RPG campaign for TFT shows that we could make a Geneforge campaign including a world map that would transfer the character from one area(or map) to another. the hard part would be character item holding, roster and the character statistics/skill point, though I'm sure some good old multiboards could take care of that. I might try this sometime soon.
Blizzard's RTS games do have good plot and gameplay however I believe that half the reason that they are successful is that they have very good map editors so there are lots of good custom maps. Some people buy war3 mostly to play DotA .
Starcraft 2 is not out out and it might just be good that way. First blizzard shows us some pretty sweet gameplay and powerful editor and then they start showing things like the menu, premium maps, needing a battle.net 2 account to play, getting rid LAN, etc. I've kind of given up on blizzard making any more good games.