I got about halfway through the game with Mad Jenny – my pyromanic sorceress who had an unhealthy obsession with rocks and alcoholic beverages – before an accidental misclick during retraining made me realize that I could specialize in the same thing more than once. At first I went, "Wow! This makes things so much easier!", but then I realized that no.. no it didn't.
If we could only take each specialization once, as I initially and erroneously believed, the decision is only in what order do you take them. With being able to train multiple times, however... Well, Mad Jenny ran around for another quarter of the game with +2 in the right-hand column, which gave her level three arcane blessing and curse for a minimal skill point investment!
I found my mind whirling for days at work trying to imagine what the most effective combination of skill points and specializations might be for my characters. For Mad Jenny, I tended to stick her with Shima and Jenell from the get-go and this prompted me to go for the 4th Tier abilities for all of the characters. Summon Drake is nice, as is Shima's Steel Tornado and Mad Jenny's Corrupting Cloud... but I think my next play-through will involve more variation with the skill choices. Maybe forgoing the T4 stuff and focussing more on pumping up the lower tier skills to higher levels.
I'd like to get my specializations out of the middle column where they all ended up (all of them.. on all characters.. I like passive buffs, I think). I'm torn on if it's more useful to use specializations to make a character really awesome at doing one thing, or to prop up their weakest column. On the one hand, I really missed Shima's teleporting and Mad Jenny's de/buffs in the last chapter, but on the other... their damage outputs and survivability were amazing.
I'm sure other people will have a lot more fun working out the nuts and bolts than I will, but I enjoyed being able to roll on Hard for nearly all of the game. I had to drop down to Normal for some of the boss fights and even Casual once! Mad Jenny, all by her lonesome, versus three nasty shadowalker types? Yeah... she's a fragile little thing.. her with the no points put into Endurance.
Next time, Hard all the way, baby!
~RG
For those interested, I ended with 444 rocks, 68 ale, and 82 wine, as well as 103 iron, 171 paper, and 214 bags of meal...
...I may have a problem, since I like to do this in all Spidweb games with a weightless inventory. >.>;; In fact, I'm sure I missed some.. Clearly a replay is in order!